Skip to main content

Alabama received special treatment from the CFP committee that Georgia never got

Georgia in 2023 deserved better.
ByTrevor Michael
Georgia v Auburn
Georgia v Auburn | Kevin C. Cox/GettyImages

The latest edition of the College Football Playoff rankings are out and Georgia kept their No. 1 ranking for the second week in a row. There wasn't much drama surrounding this, but just two spots lower fans from across the country couldn't understand how Alabama was ranked No. 3 because they already had two losses.

The insane decision to rank Alabama No. 2 goes much deeper than them just being 8-2 while there are two undefeated teams ranked below them, and it all has to do with the special treatment they received that no one else seems to get, including Georgia.

The CFP committee loves Alabama for some unknown reason

Last week Indiana dropped five spots (from No. 4 to No. 9) without losing. The committee’s rationale was because six of Indiana’s Power Four opponents had all lost that weekend, so because their resume got a lot worse they decided to move them down their rankings even though they were on a bye.

This past week the same exact thing happened to Alabama who saw all six of the SEC teams they've beat this year lose. Instead of doing the same thing to Alabama, who by the way already has one more loss than Indiana and struggled to beat Vanderbilt this weekend, they kept the Tide at No. 3 like they were last week.

College Football Bracket Challenge

GET READY TO COMPETE

Pick your champion (you can change it later). We’ll email you when brackets open.

No purchase necessary. 50 U.S./D.C. 18+. Entry opens 3PM ET Dec 6, 2026 and closes 8PM ET Dec 18, 2026. Void where prohibited.See for complete details. The College Football Playoff (CFP) is not a sponsor or administrator of this contest.

Dropping Indiana five spots because all of their Power Four opponents this season lost may have been an overreaction, but that was the standard the CFP committee set. If they wanted to do the right thing they would've dropped Alabama in their rankings a similar amount, but the committee instead gave them special treatment.

Three years ago the College Football Playoff did Georgia extremely dirty. The Bulldogs were fresh off winning back-to-back national championships and were the No. 1 team in the country entering the 2023 SEC Championship game. Georgia lost that game to Alabama by three points, and the CFP committee somehow dropped them to No. 6 which at the time was outside the 4-team playoff.

That’s the only time the committee’s ever punished a team that much for losing their conference championship game. Since then the committee has even come out and said how they don't want to punish teams who lose their conference championship game when most of the teams in the country don't play an extra game, but in 2023 they made sure to punish Georgia for barely losing to a great team.

In fact, Alabama lost their third game of the season last year in the SEC Championship game to Georgia. That game wasn't competitive at all, yet the committee kept them in the playoff.

The committee has a real problem on their hands. It's one thing to set crazy precedents people don't agree with, but it's a completely different thing to not hold every team to the same standards. That's what they did to Georgia three years ago and that's what they did for Alabama on Tuesday, unfortunately for Georgia they were on the wrong side of the committee's inconsistencies and it may have cost them a national championship.

Add us as a preferred source on Google