Skip to main content

Rams should learn the lesson Georgia did before doubting Stetson Bennett again

Bennett has proven before, if you give him that shot, he'll deliver
Los Angeles Rams v Kansas City Chiefs
Los Angeles Rams v Kansas City Chiefs | David Eulitt/GettyImages

The Los Angeles Rams have been searching for something that might already be sitting in their QB room. It's as if Sean McVay can't see the forest for the trees.

McVay and the Rams are acting as if they're looking for Matthew Stafford's eventual replacement. What seems to be getting overlooked is that they have the perfect guy for that already on their roster, and his name is Stetson Bennett.

The thing is, this isn't a four-alarm fire. The Rams don't need Bennett to replace Stafford today. They need to start preparing him to replace Stafford tomorrow.

The argument here isn't that Bennett has proven he'll be a great NFL quarterback. It's that he's shown the Rams enough that it's time to stop treating him like an expendable QB3, and come to the realization that he can be the succession plan they've been searching for behind Stafford.

Bennett has survived the inauspicious start to his NFL career, continued to develop, and is giving the Rams plenty of reasons to believe there's something there. Every time he takes the field, he's showing the Rams the same thing he showed Georgia when he was being doubted there.

At some point, the Rams have to stop asking whether Bennett just deserves a roster spot and start asking a much bigger question:

Could he eventually deserve Stafford's job as the starting quarterback?

Stafford is 38. He's entering his 18th year in the league. His body has taken an ungodly amount of punishment. Every offseason now naturally brings questions about how much longer he'll play.

The Rams know the day is coming when one of the best quarterbacks of his generation walks away and leaves an enormous hole behind him, and the Rams will be in the unenviable position of, "how do we replace a legend?"

Maybe Los Angeles should stop looking past the quarterback who's been standing behind Stafford.

The Los Angeles Rams don't need to find Stafford's replacement this week, this month, or perhaps even this year. But they'd be foolish not to start preparing for the day they do.

And maybe it's time they realized the most intriguing candidate has been on their roster all along.

Stetson Bennett has earned the right to be taken seriously

The Bennett we see today isn't the same guy the Rams drafted in 2023. He was raw. He disappeared from football for a year. His 2024 preseason was somewhat chaotic, displaying big-play ability mixed with turnovers. He spent 2025 continuing to develop and, truthfully, looked much better.

Now you're seeing a quarterback in Bennett who looks increasingly comfortable operating an NFL offense. He's got his swag back, and he's showing that same confidence he showed while leading Georgia to back-to-back national titles.

It simply doesn't make sense to dismiss him anymore, and McVay may be slowly coming to that conclusion.

In typical McVay fashion, he doesn't want to say too much, but what he does say is quite telling if you read between the lines. It seems like he's starting to believe in Bennett and starting to think maybe, just maybe...

The Rams already know better than anyone what Stetson Bennett brings

Sean McVay has had Bennett in the building for years and hasn't cast him aside yet. He knows how Bennett studies. He's talked about Bennett taking mental reps. He knows and likes how teammates respond to him (sound familiar, Georgia fans?).

He knows what Bennett looks like in practice; he sees the limitations, but he also knows the huge upside. Bennett's development curve is still trending upward, and McVay has to be able to see that.

So if McVay and Rams continue investing time in Bennett, it needs to mean something. Doubting him will only fuel his fire more, but at some point you need to go all in and let Bennett cook.

A lesson that Kirby Smart and Todd Monken learned, and not a moment too soon. Twice, Monken tried to start someone ahead of Bennett -- Dwan Mathis in 2020 and JT Daniels in 2021-- and twice the former walk-on ended up being the best choice.

Various coaches and analysts spent virtually Bennett's entire college career trying to replace him.

Georgia did it. Recruiting rankings did it. Draft analysts did it. NFL evaluators did it.

And Bennett just kept hanging around until eventually nobody could take the job from him. He kept winning, and yet somehow, they kept doubting.

From walk-on, to JUCO cast-off, to backup, to emergency starter, to question-mark starter, to two-time national champion, and eventually an NFL draft pick.

And yet, once again, everyone is looking around or past Bennett for the “real” quarterback.

There's a pattern there worth acknowledging, and you'd think a coach as intelligent as McVay would see it. Bennett has made a career out of surviving the point when everyone assumes he's reached his ceiling, and then he pushes higher.

Matthew Stafford gives the Rams something most teams searching for a QB don't have

Los Angeles has spent years knowing that the Stafford era has an expiration date.

But Stafford is giving the Rams the luxury of time. The Rams don't have to throw Bennett onto the field and pray. He can develop under one of the best to ever play the game. Just like Aaron Rodgers developed under Brett Favre, and Steve Young developed under Joe Montana, Bennett can be that next step for the Rams.

Let Bennett spend another season learning behind Stafford. Give him legitimate QB2 responsibilities. Give him all the meaningful practice reps. Build packages around his strengths for situational use in live games.

Treat Bennett's development as an organizational priority rather than an afterthought.

The point isn't to push Stafford out, because Stafford's presence gives Los Angeles the perfect environment to prepare Bennett without needing Bennett to be ready immediately.

In short, stop playing with your food and find out what you've got, coach.

The Rams already spent a premium draft pick on a quarterback. They could eventually make a costly trade. They could enter the veteran QB sweepstakes when Stafford finally retires.

But before moving forward with any of that, shouldn't they determine whether the answer is already wearing their uniform?

Enough with treating Bennett like he's perpetually auditioning for his right to remain in the building. Stop playing with your food. Put him firmly behind Stafford, invest in his development, and spend the next year determining whether the Rams stumbled into something far more valuable than they expected when they used a fourth-round pick on him.

Worst-case scenario, it doesn't work as they hoped, but they still have Ty Simpson under a rookie deal.

It's not that the Rams should declare Bennett the post-Stafford starter right now. What they need to do is publicly declare that he is the first candidate to be that guy.

And make no mistake, Bennett doesn't have to become Stafford. You're talking about a generational talent that will probably never be duplicated. Stafford was the No. 1 overall pick with one of the most gifted arms of his generation.

Of course Bennett isn't Stafford.

Bennett was a fourth-round pick who entered the league at 25 years old and had to fight through some personal demons before focusing on his career. He's a scrappy, dual-threat quarterback with a nose for heroics. Bennett can still become the Rams' next great starting quarterback without trying to become Stafford.

Bennett seemingly has enough arm, enough mobility, enough processing ability, and enough command of the Rams' offense -- and McVay is exactly the type of offensive coach you'd trust to maximize that.

The question isn't whether Bennett can do everything Stafford does; it's: can McVay build a winning offense around what Bennett does well?

One last chance to underestimate Stetson Bennett

Georgia spent years trying to figure out whether Bennett was really the answer. Maybe the Rams should save themselves some time and remember how that turned out.

Stafford will eventually retire. When he does, Los Angeles will have to make one of the most pivotal decisions in the franchise's recent history.

Who's the man to take up Stafford's mantle? Maybe Bennett ultimately isn't the answer, but the Rams should make him prove he isn't before spending enormous resources searching for somebody who is.

Bennett spent his Georgia career teaching everyone the same lesson over and over again: Write him off if you want, but you'd better make damn sure he's finished before you start looking for his replacement.

The Rams don't need to hand Bennett the keys today. But it's about time they started teaching him how to drive.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Loading recommendations... Please wait while we load personalized content recommendations